How verification works

This page explains what a FillRail badge does and doesn't establish, in plain terms. Every educator's published record links here.

How it works

Where the numbers come from

The educator connects the brokerage account they trade for the community, through a read-only connection authorized at the broker's own login. FillRail never holds the credentials. Each execution is read through that connection and written as a row, with the broker's own timestamp as the time of record. Nothing in a broker-confirmed row is typed by a person.

Write-only, on fill and exit

The record updates when the broker reports a fill or an exit. Each one writes a new row. Nothing written from the broker is ever edited or overwritten, and nobody, the educator included, can change a row by hand.

When an account is first connected, FillRail reads its history from the broker, a year by default, further if the broker has more and the educator asks for it. Past trades in that account appear as broker-confirmed rows too. That history is the broker's, not the educator's: every trade in the account for that period, not a selection.

A verified account publishes every trade in it. There's no per-trade toggle and no featured-trades mode. An educator picks which accounts to connect, not which trades in them get shown.

Two kinds of rows

Rows written from the broker are broker-confirmed. Rows carried over from an educator's own records are self-reported. They're visibly distinct, and never blended into a headline number without saying so next to it.

A self-reported row becomes broker-confirmed only when the broker's history contains the same trade: the same contracts, the same size, on the same day. The row keeps the figures the educator published and shows the broker's fill time beside it. A self-reported row with no match stays self-reported.

Paper accounts

Some educators trade a paper (simulated) account at their broker. Fills from it are read and recorded exactly like any other, and they count in the record's numbers. The badge says so: "Broker-confirmed · paper account", or "includes a paper account" when a record mixes live and paper accounts.

A paper fill shows the trade was placed and filled in the broker's simulator, at that time and price. It doesn't show a market execution, or that real money was at risk.

The timestamp

Every record and badge shows when FillRail last verified the account's fills against the broker. The educator can't hide or edit that timestamp, and a stale connection greys the badge out automatically. A hand-kept sheet can claim almost any figure, just not "last verified four minutes ago, continuously."

Broker-confirmed
247 fills confirmed from the broker
Last verified 4 min ago
Verification by FillRail
Broker-confirmed247 fills · 4 min ago
Broker-confirmed

Examples. The figures are illustrative, not any educator's results.

Contract normalization

Some educators publish figures at one standard contract per trade. Where they do, it applies to the whole account, is stated in plain words on the record, and can't be switched on or off trade by trade. Win rate and profit factor are identical either way; only dollar figures scale.

Small samples

A ratio resting on fewer than five losing trades is flagged, with the loss count given equal visual weight. Zero losing trades shows as not applicable, never as infinity. Nothing is annualized, extrapolated, or projected.

Limits and enforcement

What this does not prove

Broker data proves a trade happened, in that account, at that price and time. It doesn't prove the trade was called before it was entered, or say anything about an account that isn't connected. History goes back only as far as FillRail read it from the broker at connection; nothing earlier is broker-confirmed. FillRail's verification makes none of those claims. Where an educator originates an alert inside FillRail, the record shows the alert's timestamp beside the fill's, but only for that row, and not retroactively.

Suspension and revocation

A badge suspends automatically the moment a broker connection drops or an account stops syncing. It's revoked if an educator connects an account they don't control, passes off self-reported rows as broker-confirmed, or uses the badge or FillRail's name to imply an endorsement that doesn't exist.

Commercial relationship

The educator pays FillRail for the Tracker. Educators who also run their members' app through FillRail pay a flat fee for each paying member, and once those fees cover the Tracker it stops being billed. Either way, we're the attesting party and we're paid by the party we attest for, stated here rather than left for you to find. No broker is paid on volume, reviews, or endorses any record. "Broker-confirmed" means confirmed from the broker's data, not by the broker.